[Management Edition 15] Failure Patterns for Those Who Struggle with the 3Ks

What are the failure patterns of the 3Ks for managers?

= 20 Principles of a Trusted Manager (Part 15)

Based on my experience, I have arrived at the "3 Ks" as the essence of management.

These are what I call "ironclad keywords" that I have shared many times in management training and meetings at various companies and organizations.


Click here for the previous issue in the series👇

Click here for my self-introduction👇

You have interest.
You are observing.
You are conscious of your involvement.

And yet, for some reason, it doesn't go well.


The results of the 3 Ks depend not on whether you are doing them, but on whether they are misaligned.

Today, I will write about common failure patterns.

Failure 1 | Interest becomes "interference"

When you try to show interest, you tend to get too close.

・Asking about details
・Checking the situation
・Tracking progress

At first glance, it looks like you are interested.

But from the recipient's perspective, it can look like this:

"Being monitored"
"Not trusted"
"No freedom"

The difference between interest and interference is whether you leave space for the other person.

Interest is for the other person.
Interference is for your own peace of mind.

If you don't notice this difference, the distance will shrink too much, and you will lose trust instead.

Failure 2 | Observation becomes "evaluation"

Observation means seeing the state of things.

But we tend to insert evaluations.

・Done / Not done
・Good / Bad
・Proactive / Passive

When you label someone, you feel like you understand them.

But in reality, you are only seeing what you want to see.

For example, labeling someone who speaks little as "passive."

But in reality, they might be in the middle of deepening their thoughts.

When evaluation is mixed into observation, your involvement also becomes misaligned.

As a result, your engagement fails to leverage the person's strengths.

Failure 3 | Involvement becomes "control"

Involvement is difficult.

If you step in too much, it becomes control.
If you pull back too much, it becomes neglect.

This balance is something many managers struggle with.

A common occurrence is involvement "for their own good."

・Showing the direction
・Teaching how to do things
・Eliminating risks in advance

This in itself is not wrong.

However, if it continues, members stop thinking.

"It will be decided anyway"
"It won't change even if I say something"

The moment they feel that, their initiative quietly disappears.

Failure 4 | Trying to apply the 3Ks uniformly

This is actually the most common one.

・Same interest for everyone
・Same observation
・Same involvement

This will not work.

Each person has their own:

・Career stage
・Strengths and weaknesses
・Thinking habits
・Current state

There are people who will be moved by the same words, and others who will be broken by them.

Furthermore, even for the same person, the necessary involvement changes depending on the situation.

Uniform management looks fair at first glance, but it is actually inappropriate.

Failure 5 | Seeking results too quickly

When you start the three Ks, you inevitably end up having expectations.

"I want them to change."
"I want this to lead to results."

Those feelings are natural.

However, change takes time.

If you get impatient, your involvement becomes too intense, bordering on interference or control.

And as a result, you end up back where you started.

The 3Ks are not a technique with immediate effects.

They are habits for changing relationships.

So, what should you do?

Reading this far, you might feel it is difficult.

But the essence is simple.

"Keep questioning your own way of engaging."

• Is this interest, or interference?
• Is this observation, or evaluation?
• Is this involvement, or control?

Just by continuing to ask these questions, any misalignment will be corrected little by little.

Conclusion

The three Ks are the right thing to do.

But the more correct something is, the harder it is to notice when you have gone off track.

That is why, when things are not going well, do not stop—re-evaluate.

Keep showing interest.
Keep observing.
Keep engaging.

And keep questioning the quality of those actions.

I believe that is the attitude required of a manager.

Thank you very much for reading until the end.

💡 Here is the "Learning from Counterexamples" management series.
If there are any articles you missed, please check out the magazine👇

I would like to introduce the series I am posting once again.

💡 "Stress-Free Good Fortune Sales" and "Sales Prescriptions" sales series

💡 "Behind the Scenes of Hiring (Good Match Interviews)" and "Hiring Prescriptions" HR series

💡 "10 Things I Want to Tell My Child Who Has Become a Working Adult"

💡 Shrines and Bakeries detour series

💡 Weekly messages I have continued for over 20 years

I would be happy if you could "Like," "Comment," or "Follow"!