SYSTEM NOTICE

Auto translation by AI. Be sure, accuracy, nuances and authorial intent may not be fully reflected.
見出し画像

Better than humans? I asked ChatGPT to come up with topics for philosophical dialogue (powered up with GPT-4)

Recently, I have been exploring whether GPT can be used for education and philosophy training. One method of philosophy training is philosophical dialogue (philosophy cafe).


What is philosophical dialogue?

Philosophical dialogue is a conversation where you can think more deeply by speaking your own thoughts and listening to the thoughts of others. In philosophical dialogue, you think about why you think that way, what others think, and what kind of questions or counterarguments exist.

Answer by Bing AI

I believe there is a high possibility that education utilizing GPT will become widespread in the future. And, whether using GPT or involving humans, an era may arrive where philosophical dialogue takes place in educational settings.

Elon Musk also incorporates something like philosophical dialogue in the school he created for his own children.

The example of gameplay/roleplay heard at Ad Astra, which would likely be practiced as a moral or ethical task, is as follows.Imagine a small town by a lake. Here, the majority of the residents are employed by a single factory. However, the factory is polluting the lake and killing its creatures. What would you do? If you close the factory, everyone will lose their jobs. On the other hand, if you keep the factory running, the lake will be ruined.By repeatedly engaging in such conversations/gameplay on a regular basis, children will be able to see the world from extremely important perspectives.

Learning ethics and morals? The truth about the mysterious school created by Elon Musk

So, this time I tried to see if ChatGPT could suggest topics for philosophical dialogue.

Question to ChatGPT

Can you do philosophical dialogue? Please suggest 5 topics. Please make them something that elementary school students can also participate in. Please make them interesting and unique.

First, from the GPT-3 answer

Yes, I can take on the challenge of philosophical dialogue! Below are 5 interesting and unique philosophical dialogue topics that elementary school students can also enjoy.

1. "If we were aliens, how would we evaluate the behavior of humans on Earth?"
2. "What is happiness? How can we obtain it?"
3. "If you could change the past, what would you want to change?"
4. "How are humans different from animals?"
5. "Is it a bad thing to change your opinion?"
Please enjoy free dialogue based on these topics!

The first one was the most unexpected idea. Are there any philosophy cafes that have used this as a theme? Is it in the database that ChatGPT learned from, and has anyone tried it somewhere?

What is the answer from GPT-4?

Of course, I can conduct philosophical dialogue. I suggest 5 unique and interesting topics below that elementary school students can participate in.

Why does "color" exist?
In this topic, we think about how colors appear to our eyes and how we feel them. By thinking about the mechanism of recognizing colors and how colorblind people see the world, you can learn about the relativity of perception.

What would you do if you had a time machine?
If a time machine actually existed, by thinking about what you would want to do by going to the past or future, and what results or influences that choice would bring, you can learn about time, history, ethics, and responsibility.

Why do people judge good and evil?
In this topic, we think about what the criteria for good and evil are, and the significance and necessity of judging good and evil. By comparing the values of good and evil held by various cultures and religions, you can learn about morals and ethics.

What is the difference between the virtual world (VR) and the real world?
By thinking about what the differences are between the virtual world and the real world, and what value and significance each holds, you can learn about reality and fantasy, values, and the workings of the human mind.

What is the difference between animals and humans?
By thinking about the differences between humans and animals, we think about human characteristics and abilities, as well as the emotions and intelligence of animals. Also, by thinking about what kind of responsibility humans should have toward animals and how we should coexist with animals, you can learn about the environment and ecosystems.

With GPT-4, it also explained the reason for choosing those topics and the aim. Isn't "Why does 'color' exist?" a surprisingly rare theme?

Other interesting themes

I tried it several times and there were other interesting themes, so I will make a note of them. All are answers by GPT-4.

Does the universe have an end?
In this topic, by thinking about the expanse and the end of the universe, you can learn about infinity and the formation of the universe.

I think it's interesting that it aims to get people thinking about infinity.

What if the Earth rotated in reverse?
With this topic, by thinking about what kind of impact it would have if the Earth rotated in reverse, and what changes would be necessary to adapt to that situation, one can learn about the Earth's environment and human adaptability.

What if objects could talk?
With this topic, by thinking about what kind of conversations could be had if objects could talk, and the perspectives or emotions objects might possess, one can learn about the relationship between objects and humans, and about perception from different viewpoints.

I feel these two are quite novel. Are there any philosophy cafes that have adopted them? I think the second one could also connect to the theme of ChatGPT and AI.

Also, I feel that general philosophy cafe themes tend to avoid topics requiring physics knowledge, but since ChatGPT suggests those as well, I felt it was good that the range is expanding. (Could it be that since ChatGPT is trained on a lot of English, there are many physics-related themes in the English-speaking world?)

What if your shadow could move freely?
With this topic, by thinking about what kind of impact it would have if your shadow could move freely, one can learn about identity, ethics, and human relationships.

What if words had a taste?
With this topic, by thinking about what it would feel like if words had a taste, and how the choice of words might change, one can learn about the importance of language and communication, and about expressive power.

I feel these two are a bit difficult. Although I do think they are very interesting themes.

Postscript: Having it think of themes by setting what you want to learn

I also tried the method of having it decide on themes based on what I want to learn, as follows. This method worked surprisingly well. This time, I asked it to learn about the importance of experience.

Can you do philosophical dialogue? Please suggest 5 topics.

It would be helpful if the themes were particularly useful for learning the following content.
・The importance of experience

Please make them suitable for elementary school students to participate in. Please make them interesting and unique.

The GPT-4 response was as follows.

Philosophical dialogue is an educational method that can be enjoyed by all age groups. Here are 5 unique and interesting topics for learning about the importance of experience.

The difference between virtual reality (VR) and reality: Does experience in virtual reality have the same value as experience in reality? Which experience is more important to us?

A letter to my future self: If you were to write a letter to your future self, what kind of experiences or lessons would you want to convey? How do experiences influence our growth?

The balance between knowledge and experience: Which is more important, learned knowledge or actual experience? Which is more beneficial to us?

Time travel: If you could go back to the past, what would you want to change? How do experiences influence our past choices?

Life's adventure: What is the most unique experience you have had so far? How has that experience influenced your way of thinking and values?

These topics are easy enough for elementary school students to understand and encourage discussion about the importance of experience. Through dialogue, participants can learn from their own and others' experiences and broaden their way of thinking.

The virtual reality theme and the time machine theme had already been mentioned. However, I realized for the first time here that they could be used to discuss from the perspective of the "importance of experience."

When conducting philosophical dialogue, I sometimes realize that ideas I took for granted are being viewed from a different perspective by others. In that sense, it felt like I was having a philosophical dialogue with GPT-4.

Summary (with ChatGPT)

・Education utilizing GPT may be conducted in the future.
・Schools founded by Elon Musk incorporate things like philosophical dialogue.
・I attempted to have ChatGPT suggest topics for philosophical dialogue.
・ChatGPT also suggests topics that require physics knowledge.


Thank you for reading to the end! If you liked it, please give it a like and follow. Reactions from everyone lead to motivation for me to continue writing high-quality articles.
Articles that readers of this article might be interested in


いいなと思ったら応援しよう!

Martin いつも読んでくださりありがとうございます!サポートは、お勉強代として活用させていただいております。