[#MovieReview] A Nonsense Comedy Movie? "#SwissArmyMan" What is the Root of the Fear of Forming Human Relationships? [#Podcast Episode Introduction]

"Reel Friends in Tokyo" is a movie introduction podcast presented by personalities "Mako" and "Oma." In this note, we delve into the hit movies, masterpieces, and even cult classics featured in the podcast episodes, exploring them from our unique perspectives to provide behind-the-scenes stories we couldn't cover on the show, personal deep dives, and supplementary information for all our listeners.

Each time, we summarize the key points of the talks and discussions from the podcast, original insights from both Mako and Oma, and even personal movie reviews that stem from our often-tangential honest conversations. Whether you are a listener or not, please relax and enjoy.

You can listen to the latest episode of the show here↓

https://open.spotify.com/show/4o8l9DJWMuwUht2pvkEytS?si=651713ed7b2a40f8

Chapter 1: Is this "all a delusion"? -- "Swiss Army Man" as a subjective expansion film

1.1 The perspective switch that exposes the "ordinary corpse"

"Swiss Army Man" has a very mean-spirited trick for the audience. From the beginning to the middle, it presents the "miraculous and friendship-filled adventure" of Hank and Manny almost entirely as subjective footage from Hank's perspective. The audience synchronizes with the range of his emotions and accepts Manny as a "best friend," "partner," and "all-purpose tool." However, the moment a third-person perspective shot is inserted toward the end, the "light flips" in the audience's brain.

What was shown there was nothing like the existence Hank believed to be a "living friend," but rather just a decomposing corpse. The moment it cuts to a third-party perspective, there is no movement in Manny's mouth to suggest speech, his limbs are limp, and his head hangs down. In other words, the possibility emerges that "it looked like Manny was talking" was nothing more than Hank's subjectivity amplified by cinematic direction.

Furthermore, the actions Hank perceived as "miraculous" appear to others as "bizarre obsession" and "highly dangerous behavior." Hank wanders through the dense forest holding Manny, sometimes dragging him, sometimes carrying him on his shoulders, and sometimes shouting at the sky. To the audience, these looked like "a scene from a friendship drama." But the moment a third-person perspective is given, they are transformed into the shocking image of "a young man carrying a corpse through a forest where no one else is around".

Here, for the first time, the film confronts the audience with the fact that "you were riding along with Hank's delusion."
Just as Anaïs Nin said,

The audience was seeing the world by becoming Hank himself. The reason the film switches the perspective to "objective" at the end is to break the "transparent membrane" that existed between Hank's world and the real world. It is as if it is re-asking, "Was what you believed in really there?"

1.2 Geographical inconsistency -- The scale of the great adventure is a "perspective of the heart"

The strangest point in "Swiss Army Man" is that the "vast adventure" Hank and Manny go on and the "actual geography" revealed at the end of the story do not match at all. The audience gets the feeling that they have spent a long time crossing mountains, crossing rivers, and reaching the sea. However, the overhead shot at the end presents the shocking fact that "the forest and the residential area are right under our noses".

The sense of discomfort here is not a "film mistake."
It is, rather, the film's intentional psychological direction.

For Hank, the forest symbolizes "severance from the outside world."
A space cut off from civilization, sinking into anxiety and loneliness, easily expands depending on his mental state.

When people are placed under extreme stress, they cannot accurately grasp actual distance or time. In psychology, this is called "transformation of subjective time and subjective distance", and it is particularly pronounced in survival situations.

In other words, the reason the forest felt vast was not because
"it was really wide," but because
Hank's loneliness was making the forest gigantic.

Also, the handmade bus, train car, and miniature cityscape that suddenly appear in the forest. These are not things that an ordinary castaway could build in a short period of time. But for Hank, they are inevitable.

They are all symbols of
"a desire to return to civilization"
.

I want to return to society, I want to connect with someone, but I am afraid of returning.
That contradictory emotion took shape in the forest as an "afterimage of civilization."

Finally, there is a decisive point that symbolizes the gap between the scale of Hank's adventure and the actual geographical distance. It is
"the revelation that the adventure with Manny was a 'journey of the heart'."
.

The audience feels like they have "come a long way" with Hank.
However, that is a perspective created by his despair and hope,
and he was merely traveling a mental distance, not a physical one.

In other words, the journey in this film cannot be measured on a map.
What should be measured instead is the
"depth of his loneliness"
and
"thirst for connection with the world"
, and those are what determined the "distance" of his adventure.

Chapter 2: The Man Named Hank—The "Distorted Silence" Created by Loneliness and Anxiety

2.1 The "Invisible Chains" Called Interpersonal Anxiety

(Approx. 950 characters)

Before being a "stranded man," Hank is depicted as a "man who cannot form relationships with others."
The film shows this nature not through explanatory dialogue, but through actions, choices, and silence.

Symbolically, even when he finds the woman he is interested in (Sarah) on the bus,
Hank cannot say a single word to her.
The moment their eyes are about to meet, he looks away, holds his breath, and shrinks as if to erase his existence.

This is not just being "shy," but psychologically, it is close to an avoidant reaction to interpersonal fear.
He has a conviction bordering on certainty that "if I say something, I will surely be disliked."
This belief is a typical cognition held by people with social anxiety disorder.

In the notes on Hank's smartphone,
unsent messages, sentences typed and then deleted, and imaginary conversations
remain endlessly.

This, too, is painful.
It is not that he cannot converse; his "desire to converse" is stronger than anyone else's.
It is just that the fear that he will break if he interacts with others wins out.

As a result, he continues to avoid the most basic action of "talking to people."

Psychiatrist Alfred Adler said:

In Hank's case, this is expressed in an extreme form.
His energy for self-denial is so powerful that it has become impossible for him to even take a step in front of others.

That is why his "shipwreck" is symbolic.
Before being washed away to sea and drifting ashore in the forest, he was
already a man stranded within modern society
.

He had been drifting all along in the vast ocean of "loneliness where one cannot connect with people."

2.2 Severance from Father—The "Home One Cannot Return To" is the Origin of the Heart's Labyrinth

Hank's loneliness did not occur suddenly.
Its roots lie in his family relationships—especially the severance from his father.

In the film, the father has very few lines, but his presence is incredibly heavy.
The father in the photo, the messages left at home, the past that remains untouched.

The reason Hank cannot return to his father's house is never explained.
However, the fact that it is not explained is exactly what is important.

The audience reads into it:
“an unspoken distance”
“an untold wound”
.

In psychology, unresolved relationships with parents are directly linked to interpersonal relationships in adulthood.
Whether it is mother-child or father-child,
“the experience of not being able to tell one's true feelings to a parent is copied directly into relationships with others”
is very common in clinical practice.

The reason Hank cannot talk to Mary,
cannot make friends,
and cannot return to his father,
all have the same root.

This fear is what cuts him off from the world.

It is only natural that Manny, a corpse, becomes the “best conversational partner.”
Manny does not reject.
He does not yell.
He does not deny.

In other words, Hank is
projecting the role of a “safe other” that he could not get from his father onto the corpse
.

Religious scholar Carl Jung stated that fatherhood is a symbol of “order, discipline, and rules.”
Hank's father has become a contradictory symbol of
“a place to return to, but at the same time, a place one cannot return to”
.

When that contradiction breaks,
instead of facing “reality,”
people sometimes create a “delusional world.”

Hank's forest is a symbol of that.

Because he cannot return to his father, he drifts to the forest.
Because he drifts to the forest, he talks to a corpse.

His adventure is
a grand story of escape and rebirth for a man who cannot return to his father
.

Understood. Then I will continue with Chapter 3 as it is.
The tone will be completely unified with what has come before, naturally weaving in quotes, humor, psychological perspectives, and cinematic evidence.

Chapter 3: Manny as an “Idealized Other”—Why a corpse is more human than a human

3.1 The salvation of “complete acceptance” that only works because he is a corpse

The setting that Manny is a “corpse” is not just a quirky gag.
It can be said that it is the most important device in the film's theory of communication.

A corpse does not argue back.
It does not attack.
It does not betray.
It just exists in silence.

That is precisely why Hank can safely expose everything about himself.

This is exactly what psychology calls a "secure base."
As clinical psychologist John Bowlby said, people only regain the strength to step out into society when they can entrust their hearts to someone.

However, Hank could not find that "secure base" in any human being.
Not in his father, not in women, not in friends.
That is why, instead of others, he entrusts his heart to the dead.

At first glance, this seems abnormal, but it is actually a very human reaction.
People who are extremely afraid of being hurt find comfort in things that do not move or react.
Stuffed animals, dolls, photographs, memories, delusions.
An "unresponsive other" is easy to handle, safe, and sometimes even idealized.

Manny is the ultimate form of this.
Even though he is a corpse, through Hank's delusions, he speaks, walks, laughs, and asks questions.
Yet, all of those questions are merely echoes of the words that had been sleeping deep within Hank's own heart.

Through the perverse composition of a corpse becoming a companion, the film seems to be saying this:

This is also the core of human relationships.

3.2 The "too convenient corpse" symbolizes the entirety of Hank's desires

Manny is equipped with an unusually large number of "functions."
He becomes a compass.
He becomes a water dispenser.
He becomes a jet ski.
He produces propulsion from his butt like a rocket launcher.

This convenience is not just for the sake of a gag.
Rather, its role as the embodiment of Hank's desires is significant.

・I want someone to guide me (→ Compass function)
・I want someone to quench my thirst (→ Water-spitting function)
・I want someone to push me forward (→ Propulsive farting)
・I want a partner to save my life (→ All-purpose survival tool)

Everything is the flip side of Hank's deficiencies.

The real Hank has no compass for life.
He has no friends or lovers to quench the thirst of his heart.
He lacks the strength to move forward on his own.
He cannot even ask others for help.

That is why Manny must be all-powerful.
The more all-powerful he is, the more safely Hank can touch the "world."

Come to think of it, since Manny is a corpse, he only moves through Hank's imagination.
In other words, all of his omnipotence is,

that is.

Behind the absurdity of a corpse becoming an all-purpose tool,
a "form of asking for help" that resembles Hank's own cry emerges.

3.3 Manny's "innocent questions" are the voice of the true feelings Hank has kept sealed away

Most of the words Manny utters are as simple as a child's.

"What is love?"
"Why do people feel embarrassed?"
"Why do we hide farts?"

This "infantilism" is not just because he is a corpse.
It is also the result of a life where Hank has never had a proper conversation with others.

A person who has continued to avoid communication with others
cannot cultivate "questions" within themselves.
This is because they are deprived of the opportunity to learn the fundamental questions of life from others.

Manny's questions are
the very "social questions" that Hank should have originally acquired during adolescence
.

What is love
What is physical contact
What is shame
What is affection
What is disgust

These are things that grow slowly through interaction with others, but
Hank became an adult without being able to participate in that process.

That is precisely why his heart
is still trying to confirm "fundamental questions about relationships with others"
by borrowing the mouth of a corpse.

This is the beautiful part of this film,
even though a corpse is speaking, it feels more "human" than anyone else.

The philosopher Spinoza said this.

Manny's questioning
is also a process of converting Hank's emotions into an "understandable form."

3.4 Rather than friendship, it is "self-integration"—Manny is Hank's shadow

As the story progresses, the distance between Hank and Manny shrinks, and
the two become more than best friends, becoming "interdependent beings."

However, that is not mere friendship.

It is close to what is called "integration with the shadow" in Jungian psychology.

・Shame
・Desire
・Loneliness
・Solitude
・Sex
・Fear
・Need for approval

Manny expresses most of the "shadow parts" that Hank has hidden.
The shift in values such as "Farts are the best!" is a perfect symbol of this.

Manny is an existence for bringing out the emotions that Hank has sealed away
"by borrowing the mouth of a safe partner."

In other words, Manny is in this position.

The perversion of a corpse becoming a counselor.
Even though it's ridiculous, it has a strange persuasiveness,
which is due to this "accuracy of psychological structure."

3.5 Manny's role is the "force that pushes growth"—people change through the voices of others.

In the story, Manny pats Hank's butt many times (it's a metaphor. Not physical... presumably).
For example,

"If you like her, why don't you just talk to her!"
"What do you mean you're embarrassed? Why are you hiding it?"
"Aren't all humans weird?"

Hank is shaken yet saved by these "too simple, logical arguments."
This is because people cannot change without the words of others.

Psychologist Carl Rogers said:

Manny provides the "voice for Hank to accept himself."

That is why, even though Manny is a corpse,
he is the best partner for Hank,
his first "friend",
and also the driving force that pushes him toward change.

In a sense, this is a "one-man show," but
there are things that only work because it is a one-man show.

Sometimes people can only process their emotions
by acting as both the "audience" and the "performer"
within their own minds.

The corpse named Manny
is the perfect partner as a stage device for that.

Understood. I will proceed directly into Chapter 4 now.
I will continue writing in a way that is completely consistent with the previous chapter in terms of tone, structure, humor, and citations.

Chapter 4: The "Theater of the Mind" Called Adventure—Decoding the Structure of a Delusional World

4.1 The forest does not exist anywhere—a survival space as a "mental landscape"

The forest in "Swiss Army Man" is strange when viewed objectively.
An abnormally well-organized set, dioramas with a level of perfection impossible for something handmade,
and recreations of trains and buses that look like stage sets for a movie shoot.

These are not things that a castaway could build.

It is more natural to read everything as
Hank's "mental landscape" inside his heart.

・The train scene is "a memory of freezing up in front of the person I wanted to connect with"
・The bus recreation is "the regret of just staring at her"
・The diorama cityscape is "the path of life I should have taken"

Everything is
the residue of emotions left "incomplete" and pickled in his life.

The forest itself is also close to the inside of his heart.
Places that look like dead ends suddenly open up,
and paths that felt close become far away.
It is a structure like "dream analysis" in psychotherapy.

Just as geography is distorted in dreams,
this forest also functions as a metaphor for Hank's inner world.

Shakespeare wrote:

This forest is exactly that symbol.
Depending on the fluctuations of Hank's heart, the forest changes its expression into either heaven or hell.

4.2 Why the "scale of the adventure" and the "actual distance" do not match

There is a scene near the end of the film where the forest is shown from an outside perspective.
At that moment, the audience is surprised.

Yes, it is close.
Once you get through the forest, there are ordinary houses.
The space where Hank thought he was having a great adventure was only a short walk away.

What this shows is

that fact.

For those suffering from depression or extreme social anxiety,
"talking to people" carries a weight similar to the act of walking dozens of kilometers.

・Just one word: "I want to talk"
・Just one step: "I want to get closer"
・Just one time: "I want to make eye contact"

All of that is an "unknown adventure" for the person involved.

That is why, in Hank's world,
the "town," which symbolizes connection with people, is far away,
and the "forest," which represents loneliness, spreads out endlessly.

Psychologically, when a person's isolation deepens,
they feel that the energy required to go "outside their own heart" is enormous.

The film visualizes this as a distortion of distance.

Hank's adventure is also a story of his "reintegration into society."

4.3 Handmade sets are a symbol of "undeveloped communication"

Handmade sets scattered throughout the forest.

・Inside a train
・Bus seats
・A recreation of the woman he loves' house
・A street corner diorama

These are not merely "craft hobbies."

In fact, they are
actions by Hank to simulate society itself.

Developmental psychologist Winnicott explained that the act of a child playing "house" is a "device for safely testing the 'intermediate area' between reality and the inner self."

The dioramas Hank creates are exactly that intermediate area itself.

He is afraid of entering real society. But he cannot live by just withdrawing inward. Between those two, Hank is practicing communication by creating a "safe miniature society."

Moreover, he cleverly recreates only the scenes where he experienced failure or regret.

・Couldn't talk to her on the train
・Just took a photo on the bus and that was it
・Couldn't talk to his father
・Felt himself disappearing in the crowd

He is undergoing rehabilitation with Manny within these "dioramas of past regrets."

This can be called a
workshop of the spiritual world.

4.4 "Musical Exaltation" is the moment Hank's emotions run wild

In this film, a strangely musical or theatrical sense of exaltation is sometimes inserted.

Suddenly breaking into song. Grand harmonies begin to play. The background music becomes excessively dramatic.

This shift in tone also reinforces the delusional worldview.

Humans sometimes turn the world into music when their emotions swing strongly.

・First love
・Reunion
・Excitement
・Despair
・Salvation
・Regret
・Shame
・Joy

In such moments, a "musical experience" arises within the brain.

Psychologist Daniel Kahneman said:

What Hank is experiencing is not a "memory of events," but a "memory of emotions."

That is why the musical experience is excessively inflated.

It is an "emotional soundtrack" playing only inside Hank's mind. It is flowing out into the film just as it is.

4.5 Fart propulsion = The energy of repressed "shame" moves the world

The "fart" used symbolically from the beginning creates physically impossible propulsion.

However, symbolically, it is incredibly accurate.

Farting is one of the most fundamental, most hidden, and most treated-as-"shameful" physiological phenomena for humans.

In other words, it is a "symbol of repressed shame."

In Freudian terms, what is repressed always "takes a detour to emerge."

At that time, it often erupts as excessive energy.

- A person who couldn't cry suddenly bursts into tears one day - A person who has been holding back for a long time explodes over a trivial event - A person who feared shame suddenly takes bold action

It is psychologically very accurate that the "symbol of shame = fart" becomes the driving force of the adventure for Hank.

If you live hiding your shame, the shame goes nowhere and accumulates inside. And someday, it is converted into energy that drives the person forward.

Manny says this:

"Farting is natural. Don't hide it."

This is also a message that says, "You can move forward even while carrying your embarrassment."

"When you accept your shame, you can move forward." That is the meaning of the fart jet ski.

4.6 The exit of the forest = The real world is always nearby

Hank feels as if he has had a terrifyingly long adventure. He gained a friend, fought, reconciled, talked about love, and lost it.

However, in reality, the exit of the forest was right there.

This is

an important metaphor.

・Interpersonal anxiety
・Loneliness
・Delusion
・Self-loathing
・Shame
・Fear

When in these states,
the world looks infinitely far away.

However,
in reality, the world returns with just a single step.
The reason you cannot return is not because of distance, but because of a problem of the heart.

The fact that the exit of the forest is so close it is almost too close shows that Hank's suffering is not made of the "distance of reality" but of "mental hurdles."

The writer Kafka said this:

The moment Hank's hesitation melts,
the forest returns to being a path connected to the real world.

Chapter 5: Collision with the Real World—The Climax as a "Settlement of Delusions"

5.1 The moment it switches to a third-person perspective—The "truth" the film thrusts upon the audience

In the final act, the police, the father, and Mary appear,
and the story, which had been told from Hank's perspective until then,
is suddenly pulled back to the outside.

This switch is as if the camera is telling us this:

The world up until then was constructed by Hank's subjectivity.
We, the audience, shared his field of vision and emotions as the "camera's perspective,"
and even accepted the moment Manny was talking as a "natural thing."

However, with the introduction of the third-person perspective,

an undeniable "reality" is thrust upon us.

This structure is what is known in psychotherapy as

Equivalent to an "insight moment."

is equivalent to.

The "defensive narrative" that a person has built in their heart will inevitably be shattered by reality someday.

The pain of that moment is often the starting point for growth.

The ancient Greek poet Pindar said:

The perspective from the outside acts as a device that forces Hank to re-examine his "true self."

5.2 The final trial of "farting in public"—affirming oneself at the center of shame

In the climax, Hank farts in front of others.
This is an action that would have been unthinkable for him before.

At this moment, he is doing two things simultaneously.

●① Exposing his "most embarrassing parts" to others

●② Deciding that "it is okay even so"

Symbolically, this means

it means.

Many of the reasons why we cannot form relationships with others actually lie in the high emotional cost of "being afraid of being disliked."

That is an extreme form of what is called

"self-presentational anxiety"

in psychology.

However, humans are also creatures that gain intimacy by showing their "shame" to one another.

・My pathetic self
・My clumsy self
・My unsightly self
・My secret self that I cannot tell others

As long as you hide these,
people cannot truly connect with others.

Philosopher Alain de Botton states:

The moment Hank farted,
his vanity was discarded, and for the first time, he was 'ready to relate'.

5.3 The Father's Gaze—Why the person Hank wanted approval from most in his life remains silent

Hank's father is barely spoken of throughout the film, but
the silent expression he wears when he appears at the end carries heavy meaning.

For Hank, his father is

and
therefore, he is also the core of his interpersonal anxiety.

Just by his father glancing at him,
Hank realizes everything.

This scene is
close to what is called in psychotherapy

“reunion with a significant other”

.

The wounds people carry deep in their hearts often stem from a 'disconnect with a significant other'.
Hank's anxiety was likely reinforced from childhood by the failure of communication with his father.

His father's silence is neither blame nor denial.
It simply shows the fact that only 'years of silence' remain between them.

And that silence is exactly what emphasizes Hank's growth.

Hank used to be too afraid of his father to say anything.
But now, Hank is trying to speak about himself, even if it means exposing his shame in front of his father.

This is his greatest progress.

5.4 Distance from Mary—The pain of bringing 'longing' into reality

Mary, whom Hank had been thinking of for many years.
However, she only existed within his 'fantasies'.

Photographs, memories of the bus, imaginary conversations.
All of it was a 'story' that Hank had arbitrarily filled in.

The scene where she appears with her husband and child is also the moment when Hank's delusions completely collapse.

Here, the film is extremely cruel, yet sincere.

This is an unavoidable truth for those who suffer from interpersonal anxiety.

Longing does not get hurt.
Fantasies do not argue back.
The ideal other remains silent and kind.

However,
'The real other' does not follow the story of our expectations.

Hank witnesses this for the first time.

That pain is, in fact, the 'key to returning him to reality'.

Hans-Georg Gadamer says:

What Hank did was his first challenge to this risk.

5.5 Why did Manny return to the sea?—'Parting' as a symbol

In the end, Manny's corpse rides the waves and returns to the sea.

What is important here is

In other words, for Hank, the sea is

'Symbol of death and escape' → 'Symbol of parting and growth'

transformed into.

Manny is the very embodiment of the "fantasy to fill the void of loneliness" within Hank.
That is why when Hank was "ready to return to the real world," the fantasy had served its purpose.

Manny returning to the sea is,
a funeral for the fantasy,
the end of a delusional world,
and proof of Hank's self-recovery.

Thoreau says this:

Hank got lost in the woods.
And he faced his loneliness, his shame, and his excessive fantasies.
That is precisely why Manny leaves.

The delusion was a "temporary wing" necessary for growth.

5.6 The "reality" of this film is not cruel, but kind

From the audience's perspective, Hank might look miserable at the end.
Carrying a corpse, being misunderstood, surrounded by police, and exposed to shame in front of his father.

However, this film is not cruel.
It is, rather, kind.

・Reality does not "punish" Hank
・Mary does not blame him
・His father just watches
・The police do not treat him roughly right away

What the film shows is,

the message that.

Even amidst the pain of not being understood,
Hank reached out to the outside world for the first time.

That very step is growth, and it is salvation.

5.7 Summary──The human instinct of "I want to connect with someone, even if I am a monster"

Hank had always thought that he might be a "disgusting monster."
But Manny told him,

And Hank,
returns to the real world while still carrying his "disgusting self."

Herein lies the essence of this film.

But, even so,
humans are creatures that want to connect with others.

Even if that means
a loneliness so profound that a corpse starts talking.

To borrow the words of Le Clézio,

Hank learned this truth, which is so obvious that we often forget it,
from a strange and lovable corpse.

Podcaster Mako (@_macobana) brings the movie discussion that unfolded on her solo podcast program '#YomoyamaKobanashi' (#Makobana)—where she talks about things she couldn't cover enough on her main channel 'Pocket ni Numa wo' (#PokeNuma)—to a dedicated channel at last.

There is no end to the movies I want to talk about!

Episodes will be released weekly or bi-weekly.

Please share your thoughts with the hashtags #ReelPal #ReelPal on Twitter.

We may feature your tweets on the show.

Click here for the theme talk submission form↓

https://forms.gle/4PT2GBA7TY8vAoCx7

For direct messages, please send them here↓

yomoyamakobanashi@gmail.com

Thank you for your continued support of the show.

https://open.spotify.com/show/4o8l9DJWMuwUht2pvkEytS?si=1a52009ac6d0484b