[#MovieReview] The Woman Praying in the Flames—The End of Atonement and Faith Depicted in "Alien 3" by Oma [#Podcast Episode Introduction]
"Reel Friends in Tokyo" is a movie introduction podcast hosted by personalities "Mako" and "Oma." In this note, we delve into the hit films, masterpieces, and even cult classics featured in the podcast episodes, exploring them from our unique perspectives to provide behind-the-scenes stories, personal deep dives, and supplementary information for our listeners.
Each time, we summarize the key points of the talks and discussions from the podcast, our own unique observations as Mako and Oma, and even our personal movie reviews that sometimes stem from our off-the-cuff, off-topic conversations. Whether you are a listener or not, please relax and enjoy.
You can listen to the latest episode of the program here↓
Prologue: "#Alien 3" as a Story of "Faith" Rather Than Fear
Few films in the series leave the audience with as much of a sense of "discomfort" as "#Alien 3." While it bears the name of sci-fi horror, what lies within is not fear, but a quiet prayer and the scent of the apocalypse. On the closed prison planet Fury 161, amidst the desolate mining facility, the former hero Ellen Ripley wakes up once again. But none of the companions she should have saved are alive. Both the innocent girl Newt and her comrade-in-arms Hicks lie before her as cold corpses.
It is symbolic that the first words Ripley speaks here are, "I'm alone again." In the infinite solitude of outer space, she no longer exists as a representative of humanity, but as the "last human."
The director of this film was #DavidFincher, who was in his mid-20s at the time. He would later become famous as a filmmaker who exposes the dark side of humanity in "Se7en" and "Fight Club," but the origin of that is already here. What he depicted was not the "fear of being attacked by a monster," but a "fable about sin and salvation." The alien, a grotesque entity, is no longer an external enemy, but transforms into the "original sin" nesting within Ripley herself.
The theme of "#Alien 1" was the fear of the unknown, and "#Alien 2" was the awakening of motherhood and combat instinct. However, "3" strips all of that away, leaving only the most naked parts of humanity—"faith" and "atonement." The prison planet where it is set is a closed male community where neither civilization nor women exist. While dominated by violence and desire, they try to suppress their own sins by believing in "God." Their appearance overlaps with the people of the Old Testament being tested in the wilderness.
Fincher depicts this world thoroughly through the contrast of light and shadow. The red of the blast furnace, the light of prayer candles, and the alien writhing in the darkness. Everything is composed as an image of "purgatory." There, both hope and despair are equally nothing more than God's trials. Before they know it, the audience is trapped in this prison of faith along with Ripley.
What is interesting is that when Ripley falls into this world, despite being a "foreign object," she eventually becomes something like a "prophet" to the prisoners. Her body carries a new alien—and a "Queen" at that. In other words, her very existence embodies the "ambiguity of sin and life." Standing as one who can save while simultaneously harboring the potential to destroy people. That contradiction is the reason she is depicted as a "Messiah."
If you watch "Alien 3" merely as horror or action, Ripley's death might look like a defeat. But if read theologically, it is "salvation through sacrifice," and her death is a "victory." Throwing away her life to destroy the evil harbored within her own body—it is exactly the composition of Christ on the cross.
What this work asks is the eternal question: "Can humans escape from sin?" The alien is not just a monster, but a symbol of desire, violence, and attachment to life. Humans can neither eliminate it nor coexist with it. That is why Ripley atones for it in the form of "death." Her act of jumping is depicted as a "flight" that transcends the cross.
Ripley's story does not end here. In the next installment, "#Alien 4," she achieves a "resurrection" as a clone. "3" and "4" are truly a two-part work of "death and resurrection," and what Fincher presented was a theological fable disguised as a horror movie.
"What is salvation?" and "For whom does atonement exist?"—When we are ready to receive these questions, we may finally begin to watch "Alien 3" as a "film of prayer."
Chapter 1: Prison Planet Fury 161 — A Community as Purgatory
The prison planet Fury 161, the setting of "#Alien 3," is the core of the story itself. This planet is completely isolated from the outside world, and Ripley is the only woman. The prisoners are all men, and moreover, they are all violent criminals such as rapists and murderers. They accept themselves as "sinners" and live as a religious community. What they believe in is "#punishment" rather than "#forgiveness." Meals are simple, sexual acts are prohibited, and there is no alcohol. They believe that they can only atone for their own sins by suppressing their desires. Yes, this planet is a prison and, at the same time, a space like a monastery.
The psychologist #Freud stated that the repression of desire is the structure of civilization, and this Fury 161 is exactly an extreme form of that. They are a microcosm of a "society that maintains order through repression," while simultaneously exposing the violence lurking within it. With the appearance of a "woman" named Ripley, that order collapses in an instant. Her existence is like "forbidden fruit" to the men who have been suppressing their desires, and it is nothing less than a trial from God.
The desolate landscape of the planet reminds one of the "wilderness" in the Old Testament. The desert where Moses had his faith tested, the wilderness where Christ was tempted by the devil—people are only questioned about their true faith in isolation and despair. Fincher's direction thoroughly visualizes this. Dark mines, darkness as slimy as heavy oil, and closed spaces without windows. The light that shines into them is always thin, like a single ray of light through which God's grace faintly reaches.
This contrast of "light and darkness" is not merely an artistic expression. Light is faith, and darkness symbolizes human original sin. The prisoners are those who live in darkness, but they seek light by praying. But that prayer is by no means pure. Their faith is a compulsive act for atonement, close to what is called "#ritualistic compulsion" in religious psychology. They do not wish to be forgiven by God, but are seeking the "right to be punished."
The structure of this community is also the culmination of what the sociologist #Durkheim called "#collective consciousness." The norms of the community take precedence over individual will, and everyone shares the same values. In a closed society where faith and fear are integrated, foreign objects are excluded. Ripley appears as that "foreign object," but eventually changes into the "center of their faith." The fact that she is a host for a grotesque creature is truly "sacred pollution"—in other words, an existence that must not be touched but must be worshipped. As the religious scholar #MaryDouglas pointed out, pollution is not just contamination, but the power itself that shakes boundaries.
Fincher also expresses this structure through the rhythm of the visuals. Long silences, low bass sounds, and sudden screams. This is like a ritual of worship. Prayer and fear visit alternately, and the audience is caught up in those waves. The moment Ripley is welcomed into the community, a prisoner says, "She fell from heaven." It does not sound like irony, but like a literal "revelation."
While they carry their sins, they believe in "salvation" somewhere. But that salvation does not come from the outside. The outside world—corporations, science, power—has abandoned them. That is why they have no choice but to find God within. Ripley's existence is the embodiment of that "inner God," and eventually becomes a mirror that tests their faith.
Fury 161 is not a world that has lost hope. Rather, it is a place that proves "hope is only born within despair." To what extent can a person burdened with sin pray? It is a purgatory for staring into that limit. As we peer into that darkness, we are unconsciously being asked where our own sins lie.
Chapter 2: Ripley—The Incarnate Savior
Ripley is the protagonist who has been defined most by her "body" in the history of science fiction cinema. In #Alien, she symbolizes survival instinct; in #Aliens, motherhood; and in #Alien3, "incarnation." In other words, she has become an existence that questions "what is human" not through spirit, but through the body itself. Within her body, she carries the #QueenAlien, which is both enemy and child. It is a metaphor that embodies a "body burdened with sin." Ripley carries both the "seed of destruction" and the "possibility of salvation" within her own body simultaneously.
Theologically, this duality is the very structure of #JesusChrist. While Christ was the Son of God, he was also the Son of Man. He was a perfect being who simultaneously lived in a body that felt suffering and desire. Ripley is also depicted as an "intermediary" standing on the boundary between science/technology and biology, between the sacred and the profane. She stands between human and alien, belonging fully to neither. She is like the "incarnate Christ" who mediates between God and man.
What is depicted through her body is a story of #atonement and #self-sacrifice. Ripley does not try to eliminate the "evil" lurking within her. Instead, she accepts it and lives with it until the end. Psychologically speaking, this is a process of "#acceptance." The more one rejects suffering, the more one is controlled by it. Ripley knows this. That is why she does not run away. She continues to live quietly, as if praying, while carrying the alien within her. Her figure is not that of one chosen by God, but rather one "forsaken by God."
This brings to mind the philosophy of #suffering found in Dostoevsky's "The Brothers Karamazov." The paradox that one can only be free by bearing sin and taking on the pain of others as one's own. Ripley walks exactly that path. To save others, she takes their sins into her own body. Moreover, she does this not because she was ordered to, but by her own will. That is the core of the "female Christ" figure depicted by Fincher.
Ripley's physicality also carries the symbolism of a "#motherly_existence." In "Aliens," she was a "mother" protecting her adopted daughter Newt, but in "3," she becomes an "evil mother." What she carries in her womb is a "reverse motherhood" with the potential to destroy humanity. But that is precisely why Ripley's love is purified. Destructive motherhood—sealing that away through her own death is the ultimate self-sacrifice and a form of the mother-god's love. The psychologist #Jung defined motherhood as an "archetype containing both creation and destruction," and Ripley is the very embodiment of that symbol.
Ripley's gaze is always quiet. She does not explode with anger; she simply "endures." This "silent passion" makes her Christ-like. She does not defeat the alien; she accepts it and dies with it. That act is not violence, but a "prayer." When she finally throws herself into the furnace, her figure is depicted with arms outstretched, much like Christ on the cross. But Ripley does not beg for salvation. She chooses it herself and falls. That fall does not look like "death," but rather like an "ascension."
In that moment, "fear" disappears from the audience. What remains is a quiet piety. Even though it is a horror movie, we shed tears. This is because her death is not a defeat, but a liberation. When she burns away the "evil" she carried within her, human "sin" is simultaneously forgiven. In other words, Ripley dies as a "proxy for humanity" crucified on a cosmic cross.
Chapter 3: The Transformation of the Prisoners—From Sinners to Believers
The prisoners in #Alien3 do not live by faith from the beginning. They are people who can only maintain themselves by "receiving punishment" amidst a vortex of violence and desire. Sex offenders, murderers, thieves—each one is an existence completely cast out by society. But eventually, they transform into "those who pray." Ripley is at the center of that change. She is neither a god nor a savior. In fact, to them, she was initially a "foreign object that shakes their faith."
Immediately after Ripley crashes, the prisoners show blatant disgust and desire. The excitement of how many years it has been since they saw a woman. But at the same time, the fear that she is an existence that defiles this "sanctuary of abstinence." Psychologically speaking, this is the phenomenon of "#projection." They project their own desires onto Ripley and reject her existence as a "demonic temptation." Their actions to try and exclude Ripley are, in fact, nothing more than an expression of their fear of not wanting to see their own sins.
However, once the alien attacks begin, the situation changes completely. Their faith is tested and then reorganized. Those who are sacrificed first run wild in fear. They run around, curse each other, and betray one another. But eventually, when they witness Ripley leading everyone by sacrificing herself, "faith" is reignited within them. For the first time, they pray "not for themselves, but for someone else."
This change can be called the reversal of "#deindividuation" in social psychology. In a closed society, people lose responsibility within a group and easily become violent. However, Ripley's presence reversed that direction. Her sacrifice turned them into "those who share a common sin." A community of violence transforms into a community of prayer—this process is the quietest miracle of "Alien 3."
Particularly impressive is the scene where the prisoners form a circle and offer a prayer before their final operation. They know that no one will survive. Even so, they do not run. The prayer they recite here is no longer one asking God for forgiveness, but one pledging a "resolve to die together." This is truly a ritual of #martyrdom. Ripley's "passion" leads them, and they begin to walk the path as "disciples."
Fincher depicts this change not through flashy direction, but through the shadows on the actors' faces. Faces covered in sweat and soot eventually change into calm expressions. That stillness is the "light of resignation" possessed only by those who have transcended fear. They no longer wish to be saved. Instead, they find value in "saving others." What is there is not so much faith as it is "resolve."
This composition reminds one of the relationship between Christ and his disciples. Just as the disciples who initially betrayed, doubted, and feared eventually formed a community after Christ's death, the prisoners become "believers" through Ripley's death. Their faith is not supported by institutions or doctrines, but by the "memories of those who witnessed death." It is a faith inherited not through words, but through silence.
Psychologically, this process is also a "#re-meaning_of_trauma." By sharing fear and guilt, people can convert them into "meaningful suffering." Faced with the absolute violence of the alien, they gained "meaning" for the first time. They die not to survive, but to atone. The community born there is no longer a prison, but a "church."
The moment Ripley jumps into the furnace at the end, one of the prisoners looks up to the heavens and whispers, "God has welcomed her." They no longer need forgiveness from the outside world. Their god is in those flames. What Fincher depicted in this work was the sprout of "faith" blooming at the bottom of hell, and a form of "salvation" that can only be born within sin.
Chapter 4: The Alien—The Other as a Demon
In "Alien 3," the Alien is no longer a "monster." It is not depicted as a tangible "evil," but as an invisible "#trial." Its black, glistening body seems like darkness condensed. Yet, its existence is not merely a symbol of terror. For Ripley and the prisoners, the Alien is an "agent of atonement" granted by God—in other words, a "#devil" that tests them.
In the "Book of Revelation," the "Beast" appears as a harbinger of the end times. It is a destroyer of the world, but simultaneously a presence that tests faith. Fincher's Alien occupies exactly this position. This "beast" that has descended into the hellish, enclosed space of Fury 161 functions as a mirror that exposes the purity of the sinners' faith. Those who succumb to fear and flee, those who sacrifice others to survive, and those who sacrifice themselves to stand against it—the Alien is also the hand of God that sorts them.
What is interesting is that in this work, the Alien functions not as a "#jailer" but as a "judge." The prisoners are people punished by their sentences, but with the arrival of the Alien, they are put on "retrial." In other words, their faith is being measured to see if it is genuine. Psychologically speaking, this is an experimental apparatus for "#moral judgment under extreme conditions"—where human nature is revealed precisely in the midst of terror.
Fincher embeds this structure into the way the Alien is "shown" as well. The camera films the prisoners from the Alien's perspective, but it is not merely the eye of a predator. It observes them in silence, as if it were the "gaze of God." That camerawork gives the audience the sensation of "being watched." It is an experience of what #Lacan calls the "gaze of the Other." We intend to be peeking from outside the screen, but before we know it, we are being stared back at. The terror is not outside, but "inside."
This motif of the "inner devil" is consistent with the core of the series, but in "3," it functions more clearly as "religious introspection." Ripley does not try to kill the Alien. She accepts it as "part of herself" and chooses the path of dying with it in the end. People cannot be saved by destroying the devil, but only by embracing it—that paradox is at the theological heart of this film.
This also overlaps with the concept of the "Shadow" as described by #CarlJung. Humans harbor evil within themselves, and the more they suppress it, the more it inflates within the unconscious. Ripley does not run away; she engages with that shadow. The moment she throws herself into the furnace, the Alien fetus moves within her chest. It is a choice not to "kill" but to "end together"—in other words, a symbol of reconciliation. Not to deny the devil, but to embrace it. This is the form of "salvation" in "Alien 3."
Furthermore, the design of the Alien itself contains a "religious perversion." The shape of its head resembles a fetus, fusing images of birth and death. The second mouth that thrusts out from its maw is a structure that seems to invert the ritual of the "Eucharist." Just as Christ gave bread and wine to save his followers, the Alien pierces people with its mouth, granting them death. What we have here is a world where God's love has been inverted into the violence of the devil—it is truly a fable for the age of "#atonement without God."
And the existence of this "devil" tests not only the prisoners but also the faith of us, the audience. In the darkness of the screen, we see "things we should not see" over and over again. We want to run, but we cannot look away. What lurks there is not terror, but a "sense of complicity." As we watch Ripley's suffering, we think somewhere that "it can't be helped." Humans are creatures who want to see terror and are beings who find comfort in the sacrifices of others. The Alien is exposing that "sin of watching" within us ourselves.
What Fincher questions in this work is the fundamental problem of "in whom does evil reside?" The Alien is not an external enemy, but a mirror that reflects the form of faith. Violence, desire, terror—these are all things that lurk inside humans. The devil is the "shadow of God" created by humans.
And when Ripley dies carrying that evil, the audience faces the "shadow" within themselves. What remains is not mere terror, but a quiet premonition of forgiveness. Her figure, sinking while embracing the devil, is exactly like "the moment a human who has turned their back on God tries to touch God once more."
Chapter 5 Final Chapter: Ripley's Flight — The Paradox of "Salvation through Death"
The final scene where Ripley throws herself into the furnace is the quietest and most sublime moment in the entire series. There is no music or dialogue, just the light of the flames enveloping her body. Her figure, falling with arms spread wide alongside the Alien deep within her chest, is the very image of #crucifixion. However, this "fall" is not death, but "#flight." Fincher captures that movement in backlight, leading the audience's perspective toward the heavens. The flames are not hell, but the light of purification. Death is depicted not as an end, but as the beginning of salvation.
What she chose was not "to run away," but "to accept and sink." Sacrificing herself to destroy the Alien—that is not a rational judgment, but an ethical decision. As the philosopher #Kant says, a true moral act is "an act performed not for the sake of the result, but for the sake of duty." Ripley chooses death not for the sake of humanity, but for the sake of "her own conscience." She follows neither the orders of the corporation nor the dogmas of religion. Her death is not for anyone else, but a "prayer to face her own sins."
In that sense, her end can be read as the "restoration of the subject." In "Alien 1 & 2," she was always "one who is kept alive." Used by the corporation, ordered by the military, and toyed with by fate. But in "3," for the first time, she reclaims the right to "decide her own death for herself." This is a liberation from a world dominated by others, and truly "freedom through death." To borrow the words of #Sartre, "humans complete their freedom only through death."
And her death changes the lives of the prisoners around her. They look up at Ripley's flight and bow their heads in silence. No one cries. No one screams. They simply feel that they have been "saved" beyond the flames. What is depicted here is not emotion, but a "sharing of prayer." To them, Ripley was not a dead savior, but "a human who shared their sins." To be saved is for someone to understand your sins. That empathy might be the most human form of salvation.
Even more interesting is the point that this "salvation through death" is transformed into "#resurrection" in the next work, "#Alien 4: Resurrection." Ripley gains life again as a clone, but she is no longer a pure human. She is revived as a new existence fused with an Alien. Theologically speaking, "3" and "4" are a two-part work of "passion and resurrection," and also a fable concerning the evolution of humanity. In other words, Ripley, who sacrificed her humanity in "3," is reborn as a "new human" in "4." Her death was not a defeat, but a rite of passage for transformation.
This structure is isomorphic to the "#rebirth myth" pointed out by #MirceaEliade's mythology. The hero is revived in a new form through death. The burned body becomes ash, and life sprouts from that ash. The scene where Ripley's body sinks into the smelter faithfully reproduces that archetypal image. The flames are not destruction, but a preliminary stage for creation, and death is preparation for "reincarnation."
However, this salvation is by no means sweet. Ripley's face is not in peace, but in pain. She fears death, yet she does not close her eyes. That "gaze where terror and resolve coexist" depicts her not as a saint, but as a "human." That is precisely why the audience sheds tears. She is not a god. She harbors weakness, and while afraid, she chooses death for the sake of others. What is there is the most beautiful fragility of humans, and the most realistic hope.
Ultimately, Ripley's flight becomes a symbol of "#self-transcendence." She transcends gender, species, and even the boundary between life and death. She is no longer human, a mother, or a warrior. Her figure disappearing into the flames is a "prayer" itself that transcends the framework of "existence." She did not burn out, but "turned into light." And that light continues to remain in the hearts of the audience as the final hope that illuminates the darkness of despair.
Conclusion: Is there still "salvation"?
'Alien 3,' which closes with Ripley's immolation, is a story of salvation, but at the same time, it is the very question of whether 'salvation' even exists.
Her death certainly saved the world. However, it is a 'peace that can only be established by her alone being sacrificed.' In other words, the salvation of others is always built upon someone else's loss. What we have here is a #Christian structure of atonement—and the limitations of us humans who have no choice but to accept it.
The pain emitted by this film lies not in the imagery of violence or terror, but in the '#structure of silence' itself. Ripley does not scream. The prisoners do not cry. The story ends quietly without anyone labeling it a 'tragedy.' Yet, it is within that silence that the deepest prayer resides. Those who witnessed her death do not speak. They cannot speak. If what psychology calls #PostTraumaticGrowth (PTG) is the power to continue living while carrying pain that cannot be put into words, then Ripley's death is surely the symbol of that.
Fincher tells this 'silence' through the rhythm of the visuals. The creaking of metal, the sound of the wind, the voices of prayer heard in the distance. Every sound emphasizes 'emptiness.' It seems as though there is faith, but in reality, no one believes in God. It seems as though there is hope, but no one can grasp it. This silent universe is a metaphor for our modern age where we feel the absence of God, and it is the 'echo of prayer' after the age of religion has ended.
Yet, it is within that void that '#human faith' is born. Even if no one is watching, one prays. Even if no one will save them, they try to save someone else. This is no longer religion, but 'ethics.' Ripley did not seek forgiveness from anyone until the very end. She chose not to be 'forgiven by God,' but to 'offer herself for the sake of others.' What exists there is not submission to God, but human dignity—what could be called 'atheistic faith'—born from self-determination.
In this respect, 'Alien 3' is also a film of #existentialism. It is in the midst of despair that people are asked the meaning of their choices. As #Camus showed in 'The Myth of Sisyphus,' 'creating meaning in a meaningless world' is the very essence of human freedom. Ripley exercised that freedom in the most brutal form. Her 'death' was an act of carving meaning into a meaningless universe.
And we, the audience, are tested by witnessing that choice. When we feel her death is 'beautiful,' we are unknowingly affirming that sacrifice. In other words, Ripley's salvation drama is also an 'ethics test' for the audience itself. If someone is sacrificed, is the world saved? The film throws that question at everyone who watches it.
The resurrection in '#Alien: Resurrection' is a sequel in terms of the story, but symbolically, it is also proof of the 'impossibility of forgiveness.' Ripley is born again, but she is no longer human. In other words, true salvation no longer appears in human form. Her rebirth is a 'miracle in a world without God,' and at the same time, a confession of the 'limitations of the human species.'
So, how do we live? No one can throw themselves into the fire like Ripley. But we can carry someone else's pain and wish for forgiveness. What 'Alien 3' left behind is not a 'story of atonement,' but an 'ethics of empathy.' Perhaps salvation is not a perfect solution, but the very act of 'sharing pain' itself.
The movie discussion that unfolded on the podcast program '#Yomoyamakobanashi' (#Makobana), where podcaster Mako (@_macobana) talks solo about various things that couldn't be covered on the main channel 'Pocket ni Numa wo' ( #PokeNuma ), has finally come to a specialized channel.
There is no end to the movies I want to talk about!
Episodes will be released weekly or bi-weekly.
Please tweet your thoughts with #ReelPal .
The tweets we receive may be featured on the program.
Click here for the theme talk submission form↓
For direct messages, please send them here↓
Thank you for your continued support of the program.