Does a Correct Form Exist in Youth Baseball?

When I was a child, I was taught many things by my coaches.

• Keep your elbows tucked in when you hit.

• Hold a piece of paper under your arm and swing without letting it drop.

• Always catch ground balls directly in front of your body.

I played baseball while receiving such instructions.

Back then, I thought that was the correct form.

But it is different now.

Currently, the mainstream view is that you should not force your elbows to be tucked in.

Regarding catching ground balls, it is also said that catching them directly in front is not necessarily the correct answer.

The "correct form" I was taught as a child can no longer be called correct today.

So, does a correct form exist in baseball?

I believe it does not.

Does a correct form really exist?

To be precise, I believe that a "correct form common to everyone" does not exist.

For example, catching a ground ball.

What is the purpose?

Is it to catch it in front of you?

No.

It is to throw to first base and get the batter-runner out.

If you can achieve that purpose,

• Whether you catch it in front,

• whether you catch it with a reverse single,

• whether you move around to catch it,

essentially, none of that matters.

What is important is the result, not the form.

Batting is the same.

Batting is the same as well.

The goal is not to swing with a beautiful form.

• To hit a strong ball,

• to get a hit,

• to get on base,

• to score runs,

that is what matters.

If you can achieve that goal, your stance and swing path can be whatever works for you.

In fact, the forms of professional baseball players are surprisingly different.

Yet, they still produce results.

If there were only one correct form, everyone would have the same form.

But reality is not like that.

Bodies differ from person to person.

This is because every human body is different.

• Height

• Weight

• Arm length

• Muscle strength

• Flexibility

• Sense

Everything is different.

Naturally, the movements that allow one to exert maximum power with their own body are also different.

That is precisely why the optimal form for one child is not necessarily optimal for another.

I believe this is something we must not forget.

Are coaches teaching too much form?

However, in youth baseball, there are times when the form itself is treated as the correct answer.

"Stand like this."

"Catch like this."

"Swing like this."

Of course, it is important to teach the basics to beginners.

I do not mean to say that it is better to teach nothing at all.

However, those basics sometimes become absolute rules before we know it.

Even when a child is getting results,

"Your form is wrong, so fix it."

It is said that.

I feel a sense of discomfort with that.

Coaching meant with good intentions can sometimes erase individuality.

Perhaps that child is achieving results precisely because of that form.

However, as a result of adults trying to correct it for the child's own good, they may end up erasing the strengths the child originally possessed.

In youth baseball,

there are times when "not erasing a child's strengths" is more important than "teaching the correct form."

That is what I think.

What should be taught is the purpose, not the form.

Shouldn't youth baseball coaches be teaching the purpose rather than the form itself?

Why perform that movement?

Why catch it that way?

Why swing like that?

Once they understand the purpose, the children can find the final form for themselves.

Children are not copies of their coaches.

Each one has a different body and each one has different sensations.

That is precisely why it is okay for each individual to have a different answer.

I believe that there is no absolute correct form in youth baseball. I think so.

I post every day, so please follow me.