Why are Japanese people drawn to "medieval fantasy"?

In Japan, stories set in a medieval European-style world have maintained strong popularity for many years. Swords and magic, castles and knights, kingdoms and guilds. This style has permeated a wide range of media, including manga, anime, games, and novels.

Why are Japanese people so drawn to "medieval fantasy"?

I will carefully organize the reasons from multiple perspectives: historical background, cultural structure, the development of the entertainment industry, and psychological factors.

1. The "West" was accepted as an object of admiration

In Japan, Western culture has long been perceived as a "symbol of modernization." Since the Meiji Restoration, Westernization has progressed in many areas, including institutions, military, architecture, clothing, and academics, and in the process, the "West" spread with an image of rationality and sophistication.

Furthermore, after the war, European imagery was imported as a form of romance through film and literature. Stone castles, majestic cathedrals, and the spirit of chivalry. Because these landscapes do not exist in Japanese living spaces, they took on a strong sense of being from another world.

This "distance from reality" keeps the margins for imagination wide. Because it is unfamiliar, it can be freely reconstructed.

2. The decisive influence of game culture

When discussing the spread of medieval fantasy in Japan, the existence of home video games cannot be ignored.

Appearing in the late 1980s, Dragon Quest established the foundation for Japanese-style RPGs. The narrative structure of requests from a king, a hero, and defeating a demon king has had a strong influence on subsequent works.

The subsequent Final Fantasy layered its own unique aesthetics onto a Western medieval-style world. A Japanese-Western eclectic fantasy was formed, featuring crystals, summons, and airships.

Furthermore, the translation of tabletop RPGs and the spread of works influenced by the world of The Lord of the Rings solidified "medieval fantasy" as a core part of Japanese entertainment culture through games.

The fact that the generation that encountered RPGs in their childhood became creators themselves and inherited the same structure is also a major factor.

3. Compatibility with Japanese culture

At first glance, Japanese history and medieval Europe seem far apart. However, there are many commonalities in their narrative structures.

・Social structures with class systems, ・Relationships of loyalty between lord and vassal, ・Close-quarters combat using weapons, ・Supernatural views such as yokai and spirits

Hierarchical societies and samurai culture also existed in Japan's Sengoku and Heian periods. Knights and samurai, castles and fortifications, honor and duty. Conceptually, they overlap easily.

Therefore, although it is a completely different culture, it is easy to understand psychologically. This "distance that is foreign yet resonant" has made its acceptance smooth.

4. The degree of freedom created by differences in religious views

In authentic fantasy with a Christian worldview as its background, good and evil and the existence of God are strongly defined. However, in Japan, religious views are relatively syncretic.

Therefore, while incorporating elements such as the church, God, and demons, it is not bound by strict theological constraints. Magic and spirits also blend naturally with Shinto and animistic sensibilities.

In other words, Japanese-style medieval fantasy is reinterpreted more flexibly than the original sources. This has greatly expanded the degree of creative freedom.

5. A stage setting suitable for 'escapism'

Modern society is filled with structures such as meritocracy, competition, and management. In contrast, the world of medieval fantasy has the following characteristics:

・Ability and courage drive the story
・The social structure is simplified
・The purpose is clear
・The contours of the world are easy to understand

Defeating the Demon King, saving the country, protecting companions. A structure where goals are clear and efforts are rewarded is likely to produce psychological catharsis.

In particular, the 'isekai reincarnation' genre has developed in Japan. The structure of starting over in another world while retaining one's real-world attributes is strongly linked to modern desires.

6. Visual appeal

Stone architecture, armor, longswords, robes, stained glass. Medieval-style designs have strong visual symbolism.

While a Japanese-style worldview is easily seen as an extension of reality, the Western Middle Ages are distant from daily life, so they are immediately recognized as a 'story world'.

Furthermore, Japanese illustration culture is compatible with ornamentation, and flamboyant costumes and weapons look great. The fact that it is easy to fuse with anime-style stylization has also boosted its establishment.

7. The strength of a once-perfected 'mold'

Medieval fantasy has already been established in Japan as a 'successful format'.

Readers know the rules. Authors understand the structure. The market can anticipate demand.

This cycle strengthens the genre. Even for new creations, the barrier to entry is low because there is a common foundation.

Conclusion

The reasons why Japanese people are drawn to medieval fantasy are not singular.

・Historical longing for the West
・Establishment through game culture
・Structural resonance with Japanese culture
・High degree of religious freedom
・Excellence as an escapist device
・Strength of visual symbols
・Established success model

These are layered and intertwined, making 'medieval fantasy' not just an imported style, but a genre that has achieved its own unique development in Japan.

It is no longer a borrowed view of a foreign culture, but a part of Japan's storytelling apparatus.

To start with the conclusion,

'While it possesses a structure conceptually close to Japan, it is sufficiently distant visually and culturally.'

This 'coexistence of closeness and distance' is thought to create a strong appeal. I will organize this conceptually below.

1. The structure is close, but the scenery is distant

Medieval Europe and medieval Japanese society have surprisingly similar structures in terms of systems and values.

・A class system exists
・Master-servant relationships are clear
・Honor and loyalty are highly valued
・Close-quarters combat with weapons is central
・A worldview based on supernatural beliefs

Because of this 'closeness in structure,' Japanese people can intuitively understand the rules of the story. However, at the same time,

・Stone architecture
・Armor and knightly attire
・Churches and cathedrals
・Alphabet culture

These visual and cultural elements are sufficiently removed from daily life in Japan.It is understandable, but not an extension of daily life.This sense of distance creates comfort as an alternate world.

2. It is hard to immerse oneself in a completely foreign culture

If the setting were too alien, it would require cognitive effort to understand. If the language system, values, religious views, and social systems were fundamentally different, immersion in the story would be difficult. In that respect, medieval fantasy has:

・Kings
・Knights
・Villages
・Taxes
・War
・Monsters

These concepts are intuitively graspable for Japanese people. In other words,The cost of understanding is low, but the sense of daily life is also low.This balance maximizes the comfort of imagination.

3. Is 'Japanese-style' not good enough?

This is an important point.

A Japanese-style world is too close for the Japanese. It is easily seen as an extension of history, and the boundary with reality becomes blurred. For example, castles and samurai are easily associated with textbooks and tourist spots. Knowledge of the real world intrudes.

However, a medieval European-style world has

a perfect ambiguity of 'seeming to know it, but not really knowing it'.

This allows for free reconstruction.

4. Clarity of the good vs. evil structure

Medieval fantasy has a relatively clear composition of good and evil.

• Demon King

• Kingdom

• Hero

• Church

Such frameworks simplify the purpose of the story. Japanese society contains many ambiguities in reality. A culture of reading the air, implicit understanding, and an emphasis on harmony. As a reaction to this,

a desire for an easy-to-understand composition

may be at work.

5. Comfort of religious distance

Christian culture is foreign to Japan. Therefore, there is no need to take concepts such as

• God

• angels

• demons

as serious matters of faith. Because the religious reality is light, it becomes easier to treat them as symbols. In other words,

sacred, but not heavy.

This distance also helps with immersion.

6. Ease of self-projection

Medieval fantasy has narrative devices such as:

・Social advancement
・Awakening of talent
・Solidarity with companions
・A clear enemy

In real Japanese society, effort does not always lead to clear rewards. However, in a fantasy world, it is easy to establish a structure where:

• if you become stronger, you win

• if you put in the effort, you get results

This simplification makes self-projection easier.

7. 'A world that is close, but where you don't have to bear responsibility'

This might be the core of it.

It is understandable because it is conceptually close to Japan. However, because it is not Japan, you do not have to bear the weight of responsibility or history. When dealing with one's own country's history or religion, friction with reality inevitably arises.

A medieval European-style world can avoid that friction.An otherworldly psychological safe zone.This is a major appeal.

Conclusion

The reason for being drawn to medieval fantasy lies in its exquisite distance design:

'Conceptually close'
'Visually distant'
'Easy to understand'
'Isolated from daily life'

It is neither a completely foreign culture nor a completely native one. Because it exists in between, the imagination can take flight freely, and one can immerse oneself with peace of mind.

To start with the conclusion, I believe that tendency is strongly related. However, the background is not that they 'look down' on it, but rather that they maintain a distance by 'not viewing it as absolute'.

I will organize this structurally below.

1. The Japanese view of religion is not 'singular and absolute'

In the Christian sphere, God is singular and an absolute existence. Dealing with God or the devil easily becomes an act that touches upon faith itself. On the other hand, the Japanese view of religion is multi-layered.

• Shinto

• Buddhism

• Folk belief

• Ancestor worship

These coexist and are loosely connected to daily life. Gods also reside in mountains and rivers, are enshrined, and are beings that appear in seasonal events. In other words,

They are sacred, yet exist within the sphere of daily life.

This sense makes the treatment of gods in stories flexible.

2. Gods and devils as 'symbols'

In Japanese creative works, gods and devils tend to be treated as

• symbols of power

• symbols of order

• symbols of chaos

rather than as objects of worship. For example, in RPGs,

・Gods are powerful beings
・Devils are symbols of contracts or power

They become functional devices. They are digested as narrative functions rather than religious taboos.

3. It is easy to handle precisely because it is distant

In Christian cultural spheres, depicting God as an enemy involves strong tension. However, in Japan, Christianity is not the majority. Therefore,

• angels

• demons

• the church

and other such concepts can be freely reconstructed as cultural symbols. The fact that it is a foreign religion paradoxically increases the freedom of creation.

4. The premise of 'Yaoyorozu no Kami' (eight million gods)

In Japan, a worldview where many gods exist has been accepted since ancient times.

• Rather than an absolute god, one of many spiritual beings.

• There is a hierarchy, there is strength and weakness, and there is personality.

This sense is very compatible with the gods of fantasy worlds.

• Gods fighting

• Gods falling

• Gods being sealed

Developments such as these feel conceptually natural.

5. Coexistence of 'awe' and 'play'

In Japanese culture, there is a tendency for awe and familiarity to coexist. People go to shrines for their first visit of the year while also turning gods into characters in anime. It is hard to feel that this coexistence is a contradiction.

Treating them narratively without completely denying their sanctity. This moderate attitude creates a sense of lightness.

6. Weak psychological resistance to demons

Demons are the same. Rather than being the embodiment of absolute evil,

• Powerful entities

• Partners in contracts

• Symbols of temptation

They are often depicted in roles such as these. It is closer to a narrative attribute than religious fear. This is because demons are not directly linked to Japan's historical trauma.

Conclusion

The background behind the lighthearted appearance of gods and demons involves:

・A religious structure that lacks a single absolute god
・A polytheistic sensibility
・Cultural distance from foreign religions
・The ability to digest them as symbols

For Japanese people, gods and demons are concepts that can be reconstructed within a narrative world, rather than absolute existences that must not be touched.

This sense of distance supports the freedom of medieval fantasy.

To start with the conclusion, there are many examples of it being accepted, but there are certainly points that cause a sense of discomfort.It is not completely rejected, but there are parts where evaluations differ due to differences in cultural premises.

I will organize this structurally below.

1. In reality, it is widely accepted

First, as a matter of fact, Japanese-made medieval fantasy has gained a certain level of support overseas as well.

For example, the Final Fantasy series has been popular in the West for many years, and Dark Souls was highly praised for its deep understanding and reinterpretation of the Western worldview.

In anime, works with a European-style worldview, such as Attack on Titan, have achieved global success.

In other words, it is not a simple composition where it is rejected just because it is Japanese.

2. Points that are easily perceived as uncomfortable

However, some elements are prone to becoming subjects of debate.

The lightness of the treatment of religion

In the West, Christianity is deeply connected to history, ethics, and social systems. Therefore,

・The church being depicted merely as an evil organization
・God appearing as a boss enemy
・Angels and demons being reduced to game-like attributes

Depictions such as these can sometimes feel frivolous. This is because elements that tend to be treated as symbols in Japan are connected to actual faith in those regions.

Historical reality of the medieval image

European readers know the Middle Ages through their own countries' history education and cultural heritage. Therefore,

・Social systems being extremely simplified
・Sanitation concepts and depictions of daily life being vague
・The structure of the feudal system being ambiguous

They may feel uncomfortable with points such as these. In Japan, a 'symbolized Middle Ages' is sufficient, but locally, the 'distance from historical fact' is easily noticed.

Values of otherworld reincarnation

In recent Japanese works, we see structures such as:

・Special abilities given suddenly
・Game-like status
・Setting superiority over effort

In the West, values of effort and self-responsibility are strong, and this type of development is sometimes evaluated as 'too convenient.' Of course, there is a support base, but there are differences in cultural preferences.

3. Points that are conversely appreciated

On the other hand, Japanese interpretations are often highly evaluated for their uniqueness.

Freedom of artistic interpretation

The tendency to prioritize stylistic beauty over realism becomes an attraction in terms of visuals. By not being bound by excessive historical fidelity, the fantastical nature is strengthened.

Philosophical and internal themes

Japanese works often include themes such as

• loneliness

• reason for existence

• cyclical structures

, which resonate deeply overseas as well.

4. The key to acceptance is "which demographic it reaches"

Even overseas, reactions differ among:

・Those who prioritize history
・Those with strong religious values
・Those who simply enjoy fantasy

Japanese medieval fantasy is strongly supported, especially by the latter group.

5. The essential issue is "sense of distance"

In Japan, medieval Europe is a "symbolic otherworld." In Europe, it is "their own cultural history." This difference is the most important point.

• Japanese people reconstruct it based on distance.

• Europeans perceive it based on continuity.

This is where the difference in evaluation arises.

Conclusion

Japanese-made medieval fantasy is well-accepted overseas. However, there are cases where a sense of discomfort arises regarding:

・Treatment of religion
・Simplification of historical depictions
・Differences in values

Even so, the fact that many works have gained support across borders shows that the Japanese interpretation is not merely imitation, but is established as a unique creation.

To start with the conclusion,there are similarities, but the core of the appeal is slightly different.However, there is certainly a common psychological structure between the two.

Let's organize our thoughts.

1. The positioning of the Taisho era

The Taisho era is a unique period in Japanese history.

• While modernization was progressing,

• electricity, railways, and Western clothing were spreading,

• yet wooden houses and traditional Japanese clothing culture still remained.

In other words,

it is an era where the old and the new coexist

.

This coexistence carries a strong sense of romance. For example, Demon Slayer is set in the Taisho period and combines Japanese and Western elements. Also, Sakura Wars is a work that symbolizes Taisho romanticism.

2. Commonality: "There is distance, but it is understandable"

What medieval fantasy and the preference for the Taisho era have in common is,

・It is not the modern day
・However, it is not a completely foreign culture
・One can imagine the daily life

a sense of distance. For Japanese people, the Taisho era is "the country's own past." However, there is a disconnect from the present day.

• Telegraphs

• Steam engines

• Japanese-Western eclectic architecture

Modern people have not experienced it, but conceptual understanding is possible. This is similar to the structure of medieval fantasy, which is

'understandable, but never experienced'

.

3. Difference: Otherworld or Nostalgia

However, there is a decisive difference.

Medieval Fantasy

・Fictional world
・Reconstructed symbolic space
・Religion and politics are abstracted

This is a desire for an 'otherworld'.

Taisho Preference

・Actual history
・Japan on the eve of modernization
・Intersection of Japanese and Western

This is closer to 'nostalgia'. Rather than a leap to another world, it is

an imaginative return to a lost Japan

a feeling close to that.

4. Attraction to the Era of Boundaries

The biggest reason why both look similar is that

both are 'worlds of boundaries'

Medieval fantasy is

• a world before modernity, yet

• possesses the transcendence of magic.

The Taisho era is,

• having left behind a feudal society,

• but not yet having reached full modernity.

Both are 'incomplete worlds.' Being undifferentiated creates margins for storytelling.

5. The common structure of a hierarchical society

Both the medieval period and the Taisho era have clear hierarchies.

• The nobility

• The military

• The citizens

• The peasantry

It is easy to visualize the social hierarchy. Modern society appears flat on the surface, but in reality, it has structures that are difficult to see. In storytelling,

• when the hierarchy is clear,

• it is easier to depict conflict and growth.

This is also a common point.

6. Why not the modern day?

If you set a story in modern Japan,

・Social systems are too specific
・Ethical issues are too raw
・It clashes with reality

The narrative space becomes narrow. The Taisho era and the medieval period provide a safe zone that is:

・A position one step removed from reality
・Yet not entirely fantasy

as a result.

Conclusion

Taisho-era preference and medieval fantasy are not exactly the same feeling.

• Medieval fantasy is a desire for a "symbolic otherworld."

• Taisho-era preference is nostalgia for a "lost transitional era."

However, both share the following:

・Not the modern era
・Possesses an understandable structure
・Clear social hierarchy
・Incomplete with room for interpretation

They satisfy these conditions. Therefore, in terms of psychological comfort, they are considered to be in a very similar position.

[PR] Tales of Berseria Remaster - PS5

AI-generated, for reference only.